Susan Egan On Disney, Broadway, and Her Upcoming Cabaret

Susan Egan is a Tony-nominated performer who is widely known for her role as Broadway’s original Belle in Disney’s Beauty and the Beast and as the voice of Meg in Hercules, as well as numerous Broadway, film, and voice roles. Now living in the Nashville area, she is not only a performer but also a supporter of local theater, and will be hosting a benefit cabaret, The Belle of Broadway, for Studio Tenn this November. We were delighted to speak with her about the cabaret and her life as a performer. (This interview has been edited for length and clarity.)

 

Grace Krenz (GK): Thanks for taking the time to speak with us! You’re going to host a cabaret. Tell me about it!

Susan Egan (SE): Thank you for covering the event! It’s such an exciting kind of thing to do at Studio Tenn. Of course, they produce big blockbuster Broadway musicals and straight plays as well, and do such an incredible job. But this particular event is cabaret style: they’re adding cocktail tables and that kind of seating; it’s much more intimate. As a Broadway actress, I got to play a lot of characters and live inside of stories and pretend the audience isn’t there, but in a cabaret setting, it’s the exact opposite. It’s a conversation between myself and the audience. It’s super intimate and I can share: give you a peek behind-the-scenes of what it’s like to work on Broadway or in animation, and tell the silly stories and humanize some things. It always just ends up being really, really fun. As a theater goer myself, I always try to take advantage of going to cabaret performances of people like Patti LuPone or Christine Ebersol. You end up walking away feeling like you’ve gotten to know them as a person as well as gaining insight into the characters they’ve played in the past. I always just love it. It’s totally different than any other kind of theatergoing. 

 

GK: What got you into cabaret, and how do you approach it? 

SE: I never got into this to be myself, right? I wanted to rebel. I wanted to be other people and then when I left Broadway and started doing concerts full time because I wanted to be a mom (I couldn’t do eight shows a week anymore), I really began to grow an appreciation for this art form. I went to a lot of people’s cabarets. I remember seeing Eartha Kit. Oh my gosh, how lucky was I? I got to see Eartha Kit. And I remember seeing some really great performers too, who have amazing voices but didn’t share the stories and just felt like a missed opportunity. The cabarets that I enjoyed the most are the ones that shared the stories with me. And so I try and do that. I really do think of this as just being in a great conversation over cocktails with your best friends, and that’s what this should feel like, with some excellent music. And I’ve got a great band with me too. That’s how I approach it. So I find music that lends itself to those stories, and stories are constantly changing. I mean, I produce full time now, but I also perform and I think people love hearing about the mishaps, so I always share that. I approach life with a tremendous amount of humor. I think it’s the best way to get through challenges and also to not take yourself too seriously. I approach my act in the same way. There’s a lot of humor there. There’s a lot of self-deprecation. Things happen in live theater, and this is such a fun way to share those stories. 

 

GK: What songs do you perform when you do cabaret? Do you do personal favorites or the ones you are known for? 

SE: That’s a great question. I definitely try to do music that I am known for because I think people want to hear that, and they want the stories associated with those characters. So I’ll definitely be singing Meg’s song from Hercules and Belle’s songs from Beauty and the Beast and whatnot, as well as other shows that I did on Broadway. I did Cabaret longer than any other actress because I really liked the job and didn’t want to leave. So I’ll sing from Cabaret. I also did Thoroughly Modern Millie on Broadway. And so those are really fun things to do. 

But yes, then I incorporate music that either I’m a fan of– I was lucky enough to work with Stephen Sondheim, so I’ll sing a couple of Sondheim songs– or songs that influenced me or resonate with me and an aspect of my life that I’ll share. The song “Maybe” from Annie. It’s such a beautiful song. I never played Annie; I didn’t get into acting until I was seventeen, but I love the music and I did get to work with Charles Strauss. I’ll talk about the composers that I was lucky enough to work with and the music that speaks to me, and also songs that might be familiar to you, but perhaps put in a new context so you maybe hear the lyrics in a new way. 

 

GK: You’re doing a VIP meet and greet at the cabaret. What is that like? 

SE: Again, it’s a really fun thing. I produce for Disney now and we’ll do VIP meet and greets with our cast of Disney princesses after the concert and that’s always really, really fun. Sometimes I’m a performer, sometimes I’m not. Here’s the thing. They market it like it’s for the guest, right? And it is. It would be so cool to get to meet an artist that you like, and I’ve been in that position where I am that guest that gets to meet that cool artist, which I love. But from the artist’s perspective I love it even more, because the thing is, we’re talking at the audience and they’re coming and seeing us, but I never get to talk with them and ask them questions and put them in the spotlight and find out what they like. It’s such an opportunity for me to hear from them. They might say things like, oh, “Belle was that character I identified with as a child.” I’m like, “Oh yeah, same.” I like that now it’s the guest’s turn to be the focus and to be the star of the moment. And I get to learn from them. So it’s really a beautiful thing for artists. I really enjoy it. 

 

GK: That’s really sweet. You mentioned earlier that when you started performing, you wanted to be the character on stage. Do you prefer acting as a character or do you prefer performing as yourself? What aspects of those do you enjoy? 

SE: It’s a great question. I sort of have grown comfortable over the years performing as myself, but I still love both and I think they feed each other. I think you learn something when you play a character. Sam Mendes directed me in Cabaret and he had such a great philosophy, that an actor always is playing the role that is perfect in the moment because there is something in that actor’s life that can uniquely inform that character’s story arc. And conversely, there is something in that character’s experience that can teach the actor something about their life. And that has always been true for me. And so I would never want to give that up. When I was the new girl in the village of New York City I was playing Belle, the new girl in that village. As Belle would walk through the enchanted castle and be in awe of her surroundings, that was me in Times Square. So I could bring an authenticity to the character because I was literally living that adventure in the Great Wide Somewhere in my own life. Same thing with Cabaret: Sally has made some mistakes. She’s had some bad relationships. She’s looking for love. Well, that was me in my mid-twenties in New York. I played a character named Rose Quartz on a TV show called Stephen Universe, and it was the first time I got to play a mom. I had young children at home, and so to get to channel that was really incredible. There is that unique ability when you get to play characters that you end up examining your own self in your own life, in an informative way that you might not otherwise.

 

GK: Over your varied career, has an aspect of performance changed for you? 

SE: I feel like I flow a lot better now. And that is probably a couple of things: first of all, I’m 56. Second of all, I think I really enjoy riding the wave. I think a young performer wants to control their performance and wants to be excellent every time, and I think somebody who’s had more flight hours, trusts the muscle memory, trusts their instrument a little bit more. Also, you’ve just been on stage for so many tens of thousands of hours that it doesn’t stress you out in the same way. You’re still nervous. You want to hit that note and you might not; we’re always challenging ourselves with the difficulty factor. That doesn’t go away and the nerves don’t go away. My appreciation of, “Gosh, I don’t know what’s going to happen tonight,” and being excited about that, because that’s what brings the fire to live performance, that is what makes it different than sitting in your living room and watching something that’s been filmed. Everybody’s there in real time. And their energy is going to affect my energy and vice versa. And so it will be a unique experience that can never be replicated. And I love diving into that. I call that surfing the wave. I feel like a young surfer might try to control the wave behind him and somebody older knows you can’t control nature. Just ride. The artistry comes in how you carve your path in the wave. That’s what I think of when I think of performing now. And so I really, really dig it. I enjoy it. 

 

Meg from Hercules

GK: That makes so much sense. What has been one of your favorite formats? You just mentioned you really enjoy live audience reactions. You’ve done theater, you’ve done concerts, cabaret, voice recordings for films. You’ve also acted on camera. 

SE: They’re all different mediums and I think what’s kept me interested is the fact that I have been lucky enough to jump from one platform to another. In animation I can play a giant alien. I can play a dog. I can play a frog. I can play a vixen. By the way, I mean, Meg was the first time I ever got to play a bad girl. I was always the good girl on stage. I’d done five Broadway shows as the good girl, you know? And so because I don’t look like Meg, I could lean into that. Nobody had allowed me to sort of be the bad girl until, interestingly, after a Disney cartoon comes out. Then everybody was like, “Oh, she’s the vixen,” and I said “I was trying to tell you that for ten years.” So I love that in animation there’s no boundaries, but the limitation is you’re in a recording studio, often by yourself. So you just have to come up with it all on your own with the help of the directors and obviously the artwork that’s being presented to you, and the music, but I’m not getting to do scenes with a bunch of other people, and we didn’t get to rehearse it for eight weeks so I could find my performance. You kind of were just put on the spot, but that’s exciting. 

Whereas theater, you get to rehearse it, rehearse it, rehearse it. And then the great thing about theater is you’re telling the story in chronological order. And once the director is done in rehearsals, it’s an actor’s medium. You start at the beginning of the story and you are in charge of that performance through the end, two-and-a-half hours later. 

Film is a director’s medium. I will do twenty takes. I will do it twenty different ways and I have no idea which take they’re going to choose. And so you let go of control. But also, I get to do twenty different ways, and that’s cool. They’re all unique. And I learn a lot from each one of them and can apply those lessons to the other one. 

Animation was really interesting because I realized right off the bat nobody sees my face, so my voice has to be super expressive. I was recording Meg, and then I would go to the theater that night in the Broadway show I was doing, and I thought, honestly, past row ten they also can’t see my face. Maybe my voice should be more emotive in every media, not just animation. 

The similarity across all platforms is you’re coming from a place of character and story. What just happened? What are the goals of that character in that scene? Who are they speaking with? What is the context of the scene? What has led to that moment? You always come from there, no matter what medium. And then it’s like choosing what kind of paints you are going to use: is this watercolor, is this an oil painting? If it’s theater and that scene needs to project to the back of the balcony, I’m going to approach it differently than if there’s a camera in close-up on my face where I can do something very subtle. But you’re always coming from the same place. There’s just different tools in the toolbox that you would utilize. 

 

GK: Now I’m sure you’ll have plenty of fun stories for the cabaret performance, but are there notably different ways that things can go really wrong or really right in the recording booth versus on stage? 

SE: I mean, from the recording booth, at least they can scrap the take. On stage, I liken it to if you miss your freeway exit. You can’t make a U-turn on a freeway, you just have to get off at the next exit and somehow find your way back. And that is what theater is like. You can’t yell cut. You just have to go, well, I botched that up, but I know what scene we need to lead into, so let’s see if we can navigate this together. Those kinds of things happen all the time. I mean, once you do a show 800 times, you will have stories, and I’ve done a lot of shows 800 times, and so I have a lot of stories. They are so much fun, and that’s why live theater is so wacky and can never be replaced. If you want to know one thing AI is not going to take over, it’s not going to be live theater. Because it’s that risk of anything could happen that brings the magic to everybody sharing a space in a room and telling a story. It’s a lot of fun. We’ll share a lot of that. And the fact that I’m bringing a couple friends with me into the concert at Studio Tenn allows us to share stories and also do things with each other so that there’s that energy between performers. We’ll also get to riff off of each other because as much as we may plan what we’re going to talk about, we’ll always go on tangents as well. And that is a fun energy in the room too. 

 

Lauren Paley

GK: Tell me about your friends performing with you.

SE: I’ve got a three piece band, which is amazing. And then my business partner, Adam J. Levy, who’s a Broadway actor (he starred in Moulin Rouge), he’s going to come and sing some stuff, but he co-produces all the stuff with Disney with me. We have fun stories there. And then my friend Lauren Paley, who lives right here in Nashville, she’s got more influence than everybody I know. I know a lot of fun VIPs are going to come to the Studio Tenn cabaret, but Lauren outranks all of them. She is the “Staircase Siren.” She has a beautiful princess voice and is a TikTok influencer here in Nashville, who covers a lot of Disney music and other music. I love her. I got to know her once I moved here to Nashville. And so she and I are going to talk about some of our Disney princess dreams with some great music and do some takes on non-princess music with our own voices and musicality. And I’m excited for Studio Tenn to meet her. 

There’s so much talent here in Nashville. Obviously, we live in Music City. We know that. But, I think sometimes we think, oh, there’s just country music here, but no, there’s so much music here. There’s so much art here. You walk downtown and there’s more murals than any other city in the US. The ballet here is incredible. The symphony here is incredible. And Studio Tenn is one of those absolute gemstones of Middle Tennessee, doing Broadway-caliber productions. It’s so astounding. The production quality of their shows. But not just that, the talent that is here, established talent, that have been doing thousands of  shows, and the young and up-and-coming talent, many of them who go to Lipscomb or Belmont or Vandy. And we get to see them at the beginnings of their careers in these shows. Studio Tenn supports and nurtures that kind of artistry. I’m bringing my Broadway pal and bringing my Nashville music pal. And we’re gonna play. It’s going to be fun. 

 

GK: What originally brought you to the Nashville area? 

SE: Oh gosh. I left New York because my husband’s business was in California, so I was living in California. We were there for ten years and we just got to the point where we thought, first of all, most of my work is on the East Coast. Most of my work is in New York or Florida for Disney. And so being closer was better. And we were looking for a city that ticked all the boxes and Nashville just did it, and so beautifully. It’s so foodie, which we love. There’s so much art here. The airport’s great. I can get to New York in an hour and a half, I can get to Florida in an hour and a half. My husband also works in the industry and there’s a lot of production here. So it just was the right place and we really lucked out. We’ve just loved it. And so the second half of our kids’ childhoods has been here in Nashville and they love it too. 

 

GK: That’s really cool. You mentioned producing full-time. Is this producing for Disney? Is this producing for your own company? 

SE: Yeah, so we have a company called 10th and Main Productions, Adam Levy and I, and we produce live concert entertainment worldwide. The majority of it now is for Disney. In fact we’ve got seven or eight titles for Disney Concerts right now, which is a division of Disney Music Group. We have a series on the Disney Cruise line right now. We’re developing two more shows for Disney Cruise Line. We present for D23 at their Expos, but also outside of that and for Disney Vacation Club, we’ll write bespoke productions for when they do their membership cruises. We’ve done shows for Disney now in 20 countries on five continents over, with over 350 performances at this point in the last five years. So super, super busy, but we love it. 

I’m grateful to Disney for letting me grow up. They’ve given me an adventure in the Great Wide Somewhere and they’ve given me freedom with their IP, which just is a testament to their trust in me, which I do not take for granted. I get to partner with some of the most incredible people inside the company who are just the best in the industry at what they do and we get to create very, very cool live concerts. 

 

Adam J. Levy

GK: What all do you do for these concerts? 

SE: All of it. I’m the executive producer. From square one, I write it. I conceive it with my partners in Disney and with Adam. We conceive of the concept. We put together the set list. We will do additional orchestrations if we’re using tracks. I’ve recorded all of them here in Nashville. We work with Walt Disney Animation Department to get the film clips, and then I have a really great editor in New York who does our collaboration edits, and I’ve got great lighting designers. I end up doing all the wardrobe myself. I ended up being the stylist, which is great because now I’ve got a big old Disney princess closet in the basement of my home here in Nashville. So that’s always fun. Yeah, so from soup to nuts. 

 

GK: Oh that’s fascinating. I saw that you’re a class of 2026 Disney legends. You’re the godmother of a Disney cruise ship. Tell me about that!

SE: Yes. Those are really just gifts. Those are honors. I don’t have to go and do anything in particular other than show up for the inaugural cruise of the Destiny, which was great. Oh, I’m so undeserving, but those are valentines from a company that has already gifted me a life and a career. This is the frosting that I never even asked for. There are only eight ships and I get to be one of the godmothers, which is incredible.

And then, yes, the class of 2026 was ridiculous for the Disney Legends ceremony. I’m friends with an amazing imagineer, Kim Irvine, who I’ve always just fangirled, and Eric Goldberg, who’s an animator that I actually worked with on Hercules. I’ve known him for decades, and so it was great to see them honored because they don’t always get the spotlight, they’re behind the scenes. But then, yeah, I got to sit next to Anne Hathaway and the kids got to meet Lin-Manuel Miranda and I got to hug Dwayne the Rock Johnson. And it doesn’t really get better than hugging Dwayne the Rock Johnson. I’m just here to tell you that. That moment is what I go back to. 

 

GK: That’s so cool!  You mentioned that you started acting at seventeen. How do you get from beginning acting in high school to being Belle in the inaugural Broadway Beauty and the Beast?

SE: I don’t know, ignorance? Well, I’m actually going to tell you exactly how that happens. So yeah, around fifteen-sixteen in high school I was part of a choir program. That teacher created a program that introduced me to music and I had a small little voice, but it helped my voice grow. And then I wondered, what do I do with myself? Maybe I want to do some musicals? I auditioned for some community theaters in my southern California neighborhood. And that is where I got my start. 

And that, Grace, is why when I go and see The Addams Family at Studio Tenn and I’m looking at the young talent, I am saying to myself, dang, they’re really good and they are the future of this industry. That is what community theater companies do. They nurture the next generation of artists, and it cannot be done without the patrons, and I think of them constantly. Whoever was donating money to Downey Civic Light Opera, and La Mirada Civic Light Opera, and Long Beach Civic Light Opera, where I grew up, provided me with the opportunity to do plays before I got to college, and then through college, so that by the time I moved to New York I had things on my resume. I had flight hours on a stage. The greatest professor you will ever have as an actor is an audience, because they will let you know if something is not working. Having those experiences and  honing my craft through regional theater and community theater in my teenage years and through college is how I got to New York and auditioned for Beauty and Beast. It was one of the first things I auditioned for the year I moved to New York, and I mean, I lucked out, but also, those experiences in those theaters prepared me. That’s why I love Studio Tenn. That’s why I want to do this show and raise some money to support it. 

 

GK: What was your first experience with Studio Tenn? 

SE: I’ve known Patrick Cassidy [Studio Tenn’s Artistic Director] for over 30 years and it was so funny. I had told Patrick in 2018, “Oh, hey, we’re moving to Nashville next year.” He’s like, “Oh, okay.” And then I’m looking at Patrick’s, I don’t know, Instagram, Facebook, whatever we looked at in 2019, and I see him say he’s moving across the country to Nashville. I called him up. I go, “Patrick, I’m in Nashville.” He’s like, “Wait, that’s where you said you were moving to?” He didn’t put it together. He’s like, “I’m moving there. I’m going to be the artistic director of Studio Tenn.” I go, “I know Studio Tenn, because last year, they did Beauty and the Beast, and I did a little bit of press for them.” This is when worlds collide. This is life, isn’t it? I love when that happens. 

 

GK: That’s great. Did you see the Beauty and the Beast National Tour when they came to TPAC last season? 

SE: Not only did I see it, one night I got up on stage and I sang a finale with Kira Belle Johnson, who’s the Belle in the production these days and she’s exquisite. Fergie L. Philippe’s an amazing Beast. Such a good person. Honestly, it’s a better production than the original Broadway. They fixed so many things. It’s all the same creatives. It’s the same writers and music director. Matt West was our original choreographer who’s now directing the show, and they knew what we could never really fix in the Broadway production and they fixed it in this reimagination of it. It’s such a good production. And the cast was so incredible. 100% I was there. Cheering the loudest. 

 

GK: Wow, I wish I had attended the night you performed with them! Do you have any final words you want to say? 

SE: I think as far as the production we’re doing, it’s one night only. It’s unlike anything else. It’s a taste of Broadway and Disney. It’s a celebration of Studio Tenn, an absolute gem of a theatre company, that is dependent on the patrons in this city. It is a company the city should be so proud of and come and support, but it’s not going to feel like support. It is just going to feel like a lot of fun. Grab a cocktail. It’s appropriate for kids and teenagers too, if you have a young aspiring theater person in your family, come to the show. We will take the blinders off and share how silly this industry actually is with some of the best music that’s ever been written, the best Broadway and Disney music ever. 

 

GK: It sounds like an amazing night. Thank you so much for speaking with me! This has been a great conversation. 

SE: Thanks Grace, it’s going to be a wonderful night! I’m really looking forward to it.

 

The Belle of Broadway will be at Turner Theater in the Factory at Franklin November 14th. For tickets and more information see Studio Tenn’s website.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked as *